Sweet spot of amplifier power

For quite some time, and according to the audio mainstream, the relation between amplifiers’ power and their supposed quality looked like the relation of equivalence. Most amplifier manufacturers were setting their lines of products in a way that tightly associated power with the quality, which of course also implied sound quality. And to a certain degree, it is still like that.

Supposedly, power is good even if it is nominally not needed, because “power reserve makes amplifiers sounding better”, and if nothing else it is welcome as just in case feature (“better to have it and not need it, than the opposite”). Finally, today’s ubiquitous D class (“digital”) amplifiers, due to their high efficiency and consequently high power, are easily promoted and understood by a wider audience as progress.

Yet, as opposed to the said mainstream, high-end audio devotees are no longer that obsessed with high power amplifiers. Low Wattage systems are more than a legitimate part of the modern high-end audio world. So, telling today how high power is not necessary is nothing new or brave, as it was back in the 70s when Jean Hiraga came with an 8 W class A “Monster” amp. However, real technical reasons behind the apparent move to the lower power amps are not spelled out very often. And there are two major reasons why high power can be not only unnecessary but also unwanted.

The first is about active devices. Lower power active devices’ performance is superior to that of higher power ones. This applies to both transistors and tubes. And using several active devices in parallel to increase the power doesn’t help quality, either, it only brings more problems to solve.

And second, practically every active device has certain operating conditions (supply voltage and bias current) that set the sweet spot for its best sound. In turn, the supply voltage is directly associated with the available power, and the best sounding voltage is usually way below the commonly regarded safe operating maximum.

And in addition to the inherent amplifier properties, there are several other reasons why the best sound is not associated with high power, such as the previously explained superiority of lower power mains transformers.

Just to make things clear: I am far from advocating the lowest possible power. But “the more the better” argument obviously doesn’t hold either. Simply, for good power amp design, the power itself is of secondary importance.

That is about the amplifier itself. Of course, the amplifier must be still able to drive loudspeakers. But, what the mess about enormous amplifier power in home audio is actually for? The amplifier is not supposed to move the car, but the loudspeaker cone. Usually, it is a few tens of grams, and it has to be moved for a few millimeters forth and back. A hundred grams and a few centimeters would be the “worst case”. It really is not tough work. Still, loudspeakers’ efficiency is quite poor, and typical 88 – 91 dB / 1 W / 1 m sensitivity equals 1 – 2 % overall power efficiency. And some loudspeakers have even lower efficiency. Some have low impedance, which demands even more current, and the non-linear impedance phase is sometimes discussed as another part that can also increase actual current requirements.

So, how much power is actually enough? Let’s recall some classic rules about loudspeaker sensitivity and loudspeaker impedance.*

With loudspeaker sensitivity of 87 dB / 1 W / 1 m, a 20 W (that is 13 dBW i.e. 13 dB above 1 Watt) will produce 100 dB sound pressure, which is the nominal equivalent of a jackhammer. In my experience, in usual home conditions, it is indeed enough. Of course, a change in speaker sensitivity for 3 dB will double or halve requirements in amplifier power, so 93 dB sensitive speakers will take only 5 W for the same 100 dB sound pressure.

“Power” is however still made of voltage and current, and the loudspeaker’s impedance will tell their mutual relation, or in other words, it will tell the loudspeakers’ actual voltage and current requirements.** And simple power equation (P = U x I) and good old Ohm’s law (I = U / R) might solve most of your doubts here. Also, by combining these two equations, once you know the speaker impedance, you can express the power solely by either voltage (P = V2 / R) or current ( P = I2 x R). As previously said, the non-linear impedance phase can increase demands in current, but this increase is usually not higher than 20-30 %, and if impedance minimum is associated with the voice coil DC resistance, which usually is the case, and at which point the impedance phase is actually linear, then impedance phase can be mostly neglected.

The bottom line here is that conventional loudspeakers with nominal impedances above 6 Ohm don’t demand that much current. At 8 Ohm, 2 – 3 Amperes equals 30 – 70 W, and it is rather voltage that sets the limit in this case. However, when speaker impedance gets low, it is important to know that more Watts at a typical 8 Ohm load doesn’t help – it takes more current instead.

So, every speaker definitely has its own demands from amplifiers. But amplifiers also have a logic of their own. And whether you start with an amplifier and look for speakers to match, or the other way round, the “trick” is to let the amplifier operate the best way, with speakers it is able to drive, both in terms of voltage and current.


* – As a side notice, let me say that the traditional way of determining required amplifier power on the basis of loudspeaker power is mostly pointless. Loudspeakers actually have no power, they are passive components that have only power handling (capacity). It is OK if you consider this handling too, so you don’t fry your precious loudspeakers too easily, but apart from that, such an approach is in fact useless.

** – Actually, there is a paradox about loudspeakers’ operation here. Loudspeakers are normally designed to work with voltage sources, whereas their cone movement is actually proportional to the applied current. One might think about possible current-drive (counter)revolutions here, but I believe voltage requirement is a fact to live with – and so long as we are in the voltage world, we should think of the current as a consequence of voltage, associated with the actual speaker impedance.

Scroll to Top